David Norris (Independent)

Perhaps it was something different. The Minister will no doubt let us know if there is legal advice to the effect that there is a difficulty. I do not imagine that could possibly be the case but the Minister might be frank with us and acknowledge if it is the case and, if so, he might indicate what it is. It cannot be a financial difficulty because if it was a financial difficulty this amendment would have been ruled out of order by the Cathaoirleach on the basis that it would create a charge on the Exchequer. The fact that the amendment has survived is clear and cogent proof that there is no financial implication. Otherwise, to quote the late and not so great Lord Denning, it would be an appalling vista that the Cathaoirleach had misadvised himself and the House on this matter and permitted an illegal amendment to be discussed.