Seanad debates

Wednesday, 5 November 2008

10:30 am

Photo of Alex WhiteAlex White (Labour)

At a time when the predominant mood in politics and public life is one of pessimism, I join the Leader and the other group leaders in conveying our congratulations to President-elect Obama. It is a moment of considerable optimism, which is an antidote to the deep pessimism we all see around us with regard to our economy and the world economy. It is a fantastic moment and, as Senator Fitzgerald said, it is truly the end of an era. It is not just the end of the Bush era but of a somewhat longer era in American politics, which has an impact on world politics. I see it as the end of the Reagan era, an end to the neo-liberal model of capitalism, which was fostered by President Reagan and Margaret Thatcher and which has its apostles in this country, or at least it used to, although they are disappearing. It is truly a political moment of considerable importance.

Senator Fitzgerald was right when she spoke about the overwhelming sense of joy on the part of many millions of people that we saw last night on television. In many cases these people felt in the past that they never had a stake in their own country or in the political system, society and communities of which they were part. Now they feel this is their moment and they can truly engage with their society and their country.

I have criticised the US in the past, as have other Members of the House. Sometimes we are accused of being anti-American when we criticise American foreign policy. I never thought there was anything so absurd as the suggestion that because one criticises the foreign policy of a country, one is against that country in some way or is guilty of being anti-American. It was nonsensical. We have criticised the US, but this is a moment to remind ourselves of its considerable achievements and the democratic experiment under its constitution. It is an amazing and extraordinary achievement, and this moment is one to relish, not just for the US but also for us.

Senator O'Toole mentioned the effect on Ireland. This may not be a moment simply to calculate the gains and losses for this country. Illegal Irish immigrants and foreign direct investment are important issues, but we might reflect on the larger international picture. This is a huge story. Unfortunately, the contribution of the US in recent years to the international stage has not been good and has often been divisive. There is now real hope that there will be a reversal in that contribution because the great institutions of the United Nations, its human rights achievements and other institutions are nothing without the support of the US. They are, and have been, seriously undermined by the US in recent years, and we now have the prospect that the US will again become a force for good.

I agree with the call for a debate on the Human Rights Commission and the Equality Authority. Another body has not just been undermined, but has been abolished in the recent budget, and there has been very little talk about it. The issue of race has been confronted so impressively by President-elect Obama and by Senator John McCain, who brought it into the open and confronted it in a serious way. We have been struggling with that issue in this country and it is extraordinary that in recent months the National Consultative Committee on Racism and Interculturalism has been abolished. What possible justification can there be for abolishing such an organisation? Ten or 12 members of staff will be redundant by Christmas because that body is gone. Where is the Government's policy on combatting racism? Where is our integration policy? I ask for that organisation to be considered in the debate we should have on these important institutions.

These institutions and organisations are part of the public service. When my colleagues from all sides make points about the public service and the need to cut back on it, they might remind themselves that these are the organisations in the public service that are a force for good. If people want, and argue for, cuts in the public service, these are the organisations that are undermined and abolished.

Comments

No comments

Log in or join to post a public comment.