Joe O'Toole (Independent)

I discussed this matter with Senator Fitzgerald and I am happy to second that motion. I am also happy to accept the Cathaoirleach's ruling on the basis that the House knows the motion will be debated. I am sure others will wish to add their signatures before tomorrow. I accept the ruling that the motion cannot be taken today but the House should know that some of us are very disturbed by what is happening. I respect the Cathaoirleach's motion and the very fine words he has put on the record. It is very important. I am happy to defer the taking of this motion tomorrow but I will fully support the points made by Senator Fitzgerald. This matter will not go away until it is dealt with.

Another issue arises from this. I was very embarrassed by the discussion yesterday. The Cathaoirleach asked that the position of the Chair be respected. Apart from the issue raised by Senator Fitzgerald, the Commission on Procedure and Privileges should examine the question of respect towards the Chair. When the Cathaoirleach gives a ruling, the Members of the House should follow it. I include myself and this bench of Senators. We are not demanding anything other than what is required of us all. I cannot remember any situation involving a Member on this side of the House who, when asked to sit down or withdraw what was said, did not comply. That is all I say on the matter. We will deal with it again. There appears to be an independent republic on the Government side of the House whereby a member of the Fianna Fáil group chose in one situation not to support a Government amendment last week, has rejected a request from his Leader and ignored the rules of the Chair. I will say no more.