Jim Walsh (Fianna Fail)

Like Senator White, I will refer to other examples in the section when they arise. Speaking on amendment No. 3, I fail to understand how a judge can be prevented from commenting on a case which is then reported. Because of the nature of the people who come before the courts, judges will often comment in very derogatory terms about the criminal activities of some of those people. It is right they should comment and that these comments should be reported.

I agree with the sentiments expressed by Senator Norris. There are many examples, in particular at District Court level, of judges who exceed what is fair and reasonable. While I appreciate the views expressed by Senator White, if we step over the line in this House, the Leas-Chathaoirleach will call us to account if we breach our privilege. However, a judge is master of his own comments in his own house.

While I fail to see how Members can deal with this issue in this Bill, I have long been an advocate of accountability for judges.