Eugene Regan (Fine Gael)

The connection Senator Norris has made with sections 9 and 10 is correct. Perhaps section 9 should be revisited in this context. Senator O'Toole observed that he believed himself to be personally identified in criticism of the corporate body of which he was a director. This falls under section 9 rather than section 10. Senator Norris's concern that there is potential for an abuse under section 11 is justified.

There is also the issue of freedom of expression. I am not clear as to the precise legal status of the Health Service Executive but I assume it is defined as a body corporate. As such, anyone who criticises that organisation might be subject to action on the grounds of defamation. I am not sure what is the overriding justification for this provision. Will the Minister outline whether he attaches great importance to it?