Labhrás Ó Murchú (Fianna Fail)

I support Senator O'Toole's comments on the Saudi Arabian episode. I have always held the opinion that if one adopts an À la carte approach to human rights and democracy, one diminishes one's principles and vision for humanity. The deafening silence in this instance is symptomatic of the golden circle of nations, those which support the major powers and are beyond criticism. It has often been seen during the past four years and I have raised it in the House.

While Ireland has adopted a courageous and independent stance, it is important we speak out on an issue such as that relating to Saudi Arabia. An unfortunate woman who was raped and would expect justice from the state will have a further injustice perpetrated against her by receiving an inhumane scourging. This House and Ireland must be always prepared to be independent-minded no matter what is in question, be it oil, economic advantage or a military alliance. The only hope we have if we wish to continue as an honest broker as we did in the past is to be independent and courageous on such issues.