Jim Walsh (Fianna Fail)

Section 19 deals with distinguishing fact and opinion. Sometimes a newspaper can express an opinion in the heading, so that is very clear. There has been a trend to inject an opinion into reporting. It is rare nowadays to read pure reporting of facts. We may be copying the trend that is found in the British media, but when one goes to other countries, there seems to be a much finer definition between the reporting of issues and opinions expressed in articles inside the newspapers. Here, things are something of a mishmash. I have concerns in that regard. We seem to be putting our faith in certain sections that standards will be maintained and, perhaps, improved.

Legislation should defend the right of newspapers to be an important component of democracy and society by allowing them free speech. On the other hand, we must balance this right with the right of individuals not to be damaged through reporting. We must not put a hurdle in the way that will prevent them from getting correction for a defamation or injury done to them. We must be mindful of that. I am conscious the newspapers are in favour of this section; I have not heard any opposition to it. The people who might be the victims in this area do not have a voice and that is a concern.