John Minihan (Progressive Democrats)

I join the Leader of the Opposition, Senator Brian Hayes, in calling for a debate on accident and emergency departments and health reform. The Tánaiste and Minister for Health and Children has always been willing to come to the House. Some people have suggested that she should not lecture consultants, nurses, etc. People should equally be aware that reform of the health service is exactly what is needed. Over the years we have learned that continuing to pour money into the health service without reform will get us nowhere. The reform agenda exists and a debate would be informative to all Members of the House. To play on the emotions of patients is one of the lowest forms of politicising one's case. In reality the patient must come first and the consultants, nurses, doctors and other hospital staff must embrace reform, because reform is coming. A debate on the matter would be most welcome.

Some of us may have seen last night's television report of the Irish in America gathering to lobby on behalf of the illegal immigrants for the McCain Bill that is going through the US Senate. Calls have been made in this House for cross-party support for that Bill. I would welcome a debate on this. In doing so we should equally reflect how we as a society deal with Americans coming here.