Mary O'Rourke (Fianna Fail)

Senator Brian Hayes raised last night's programme on nursing homes and the need for an independent inspectorate. I concur with his assertion that, while the HSE is not currently permitted under the 1990 Act to close nursing homes immediately, it should have this right. Situations are often so awful as to require knee-jerk responses. Last night's programme revealed terrible acts of vandalism on people. Like Senator Terry, I am unsure whether we can wait for action until next spring. Emergency legislation should be introduced to allow the health authorities to respond.

The 1990 Act provides a framework for appropriate amendments in order to strengthen legislation in this area. I was reminded of man's inhumanity to man and events of the last world war, including Dachau. However, these events, which went beyond unkindness, took place in this city and possibly in other locations. People were badly treated despite relatives paying significant sums of money for care. We should keep in our minds the image of the woman who was being changed. She was treated recklessly and in an awful manner.

Senator Brian Hayes also asked that we would not express trenchant opinions on the EU constitutional treaty before the next Council meeting takes place. By that time, wise heads will have worked through this matter.

Senator Norris also discussed the nursing homes issue and called for legislation to be strengthened. I would like to embrace the whistleblowers rather than the programme makers for revealing situations about which we should all be aware. The Senator also complimented the Garda on the shootings in Lusk.

Senator McDowell claimed that some nursing homes are chaotic and have inadequate and untrained staff. It is clear that improper health care is provided. He also raised the EU constitution and congratulated the new French Prime Minister whose appointment followed quickly on the previous incumbent being booted out of office after the referendum.