John Minihan (Progressive Democrats)

There is no evidence in the report to indicate that the file was there for this purpose. When the Tánaiste publishes the relevant correspondence later today, I hope clarity will be brought to that matter — particularly if there is a covering note or memo to the Minister which suggests that the file was passed to him for his attention.

If we are going to debate this issue, we must read the report accurately. People must not interpret from the report what they want to interpret. Such interpretations may be made for political advantage or gain.

Senator Browne also stated that Mr. Travers's report was biased and unfair in the sense that it is stacked against the public service and soft on politicians. Mr. Travers clearly indicates in the report the inadequacies at political level and those at administrative level. He should be complimented on that. Aspersions should not be cast on the record of Mr. Travers who has been a public servant for many years and who has done the State a great service in producing this report.

Comments were also made about the Tánaiste, Deputy Harney, and her knowledge of this matter. It is a compliment to her that she was able to come to terms with this issue and the complexities attached thereto. As the line Minister, she would have initially investigated the matter. As a result of that investigation, she clearly thought it necessary that Mr. Travers should carry out an independent investigation. Of course the Tánaiste is versed in and holds a view on the issues and took responsibility for them.