Peter Callanan (Fianna Fail)

I move amendment No. 1:

To delete all words after "Seanad Éireann" and substitute the following:

—acknowledges the tremendous contribution by the Irish sugar beet industry to the economic and social development of rural Ireland since 1926

—recognises the ongoing importance of the industry to Irish farming

—notes the recent announcement by Greencore Group plc to consolidate sugar processing in one plant, and

—supports the Minister for Agriculture and Food in her ongoing efforts to ensure that the future shape of the EU sugar regime will be consistent with the continuance of a competitive sugar beet growing and processing industry in Ireland.

I have particular pleasure in welcoming the Minister of State, Deputy Brendan Smith, on the occasion of his first visit to the House. I am glad he was appointed to this portfolio because he is a person of tremendous competence and I welcome the fact that this has been recognised.

The similarity between the motion and the amendment is apparent. One could ask why an amendment was tabled. I had contemplated tabling a motion similar to that under discussion. Be that as it may, however, we are dealing with a motion and an amendment thereto. I recognise the sensible approach taken by the proposer and seconder of the motion.

I am as shocked as anyone regarding the sudden announcement about the closure of the Carlow beet plant. One must be surprised by the fact that it has come at this particular point. My reasons for highlighting the latter may be different from those of others. I do not entirely support those who state that it could undermine the Minister in terms of her negotiations with Europe. If we adopt that defeatist attitude from the outset, we are saying to the Minister that she will not achieve anything and that the sugar industry here will disappear.