Joanna Tuffy (Labour)

On amendment No. 29, the Minister spoke about the special role of the gardaí and the Defence Forces but the same logic could be applied to other employees. For example, it would be difficult to do without health professionals but they have the right to join trades unions. I do not understand why the gardaí should not have a similar right to be members of a trade union and, if necessary, take industrial action. A few years ago the Garda engaged in action similar to a strike. It had to be done in a vague, unaccountable way. Would it not be better if everything were above board and gardaí were given the same rights as other workers? Most workers do not strike. The right to strike is the ultimate sanction on the part of employees and it is also a negotiating tool, which enables them to highlight their cause. It is not lightly used by anybody and members of the Garda, similar to health service staff, realise the consequences of going on strike. I presume the Minister's main concern is that the Garda would not strike.