Derek McDowell (Labour)

It is important to acknowledge that redistribution is part of the reason we tax. Certain people do not benefit from a booming economy, such as old age pensioners, those who are sick and lone parents who find it difficult to connect with the labour market. These people's boats will not be raised by the tide. If we accept they are not going to get into the labour market, the only way to assist them is to use the taxation system as a redistributive measure. Does that mean I want to raise taxes to give more money to old age pensioners? At this time, we do not have to do that. However, if it was necessary, I would say yes. That is fundamental to the political philosophy myself and my party represent.

This is a complex issue, but fundamental to our politics and the choices we offer. Most important, we must offer choice, even if it is only in terms of the priorities we articulate. The priorities I would like my party to articulate are not particularly well represented in the motion.