Shane Ross (Independent)

I add my voice to the unanimity behind this motion. It is difficult for anybody to say much in this situation. I am doubtful of the value of having a debate not because of any wrongful intent, but because, by making public statements, we may add to the appetite of the kidnappers when they find they are having an effect around the world. I feel slightly ambivalent about this entire business because international political leaders, this House, houses of parliament around the world and so on are prepared to publicly highlight the activities of these evil people. This affords some degree of efficacy to the latter.

Anything one says could be interpreted as being inflammatory and encouraging of the perpetrators so we should be reasonably circumspect in what we say and regard this as something outside the normal political area of jousting. It certainly has been so today and I commend Members on that attitude. I appeal to anybody involved in this to restrict what they say and be careful they do not exploit it for any political motives. They must ensure everything they do will help Mrs. Hassan. It is obvious the perpetrators of this kidnap will take some pleasure that they have drawn worldwide attention to their crime. People must exercise responsibility on this subject.

It is difficult to know where humanitarian aid will come from in the future if these types of crimes continue. We must look to the future after the appalling situation of Mr. Kenneth Bigley and others and consider whether we do in some way tolerate or unwittingly assist the cause of the kidnappers. Where in the future will we find those brave people who for no personal reward will go to places like Iraq where it is absolutely chaotic and where nobody, however good their intention and however partisan they may be, is safe?