John Minihan (Progressive Democrats)

A recruit is a member of the Defence Forces, as distinct from the Canadian system, or even the Garda system whereby a garda in the Garda college is a student, as distinct from being a member of the Garda Síochána. There is a clear distinction. It is only in phase 3 that he or she becomes a member of the Garda Síochána. Before a recruit puts on the uniform he or she is attested as a member of the Defence Forces. Once a person is in the service of the Defence Forces, whether he or she is a recruit, an officer or NCO, he or she is a member of the Defence Forces, there is no distinction. There is such a distinction in the Garda Síochána.

In regard to the phrase "a former active member" I thought all members of the Defence Forces were active. I hope they are because if not they should not be in it. In regard to the term "former recruit" the legislation covers former members of the Defence Forces so I do not understand that. It also covers retired members. If Senator Hayes succeeds with this amendment I will have many complaints going back to my cadet days in 1975.