Martin Mansergh (Fianna Fail)

As always, the case was put very eloquently by Senator O'Toole. It is clear from reading the Bill and from yesterday's debate that this is a wrecking amendment. There are only very exceptional circumstances in which people will accept liability. This enables people to explore without prejudice the consequences and then have the right to reject. Perhaps in many cases liability could be contested but it would be somewhat doubtful and a bit dubious. One could play through the scenario, see what is the result and then make a judgment on whether it is worth contesting liability and expenses. I agree that the amendment would clog up the process.

I must express surprise at the debate on this and previous amendments. While the Fine Gael and Labour parties expressed support for the legislation, they are now tabling amendments which would effectively wreck the Bill. It appears this is being done primarily at the behest of the legal profession. Whatever about Fine Gael, I am surprised at the position of the Labour Party on the issue.