Michael Brennan (Fianna Fail)

I thank Senator Mansergh for sharing time. I attended the meeting of the committee which discussed the funding of EU embryo research. I agree with the views expressed by Senators Hanafin and Ó Murchú. If we are serious about protecting the Constitution, we have a duty and a unique opportunity on this occasion to make a clear statement at EU level. Views were expressed on this matter as long ago as December 2001 at EU Council level. In that context, Ireland referred to Article 43.3 of the Constitution, concerning the right to life of the unborn, and stated that no such research will be carried out here. At a time when the EU is drawing up a new constitution, it is difficult to see how this can be implemented at European level if we do not respect our Constitution.

I implore the Minister to take into consideration the views of the majority of Members of both Houses in making her decision. I would be surprised if any Government took a decision which ran contrary to the Constitution.