Kathleen O'Meara (Labour)

The Minister for Justice, Equality and Law Reform, Deputy McDowell, constantly reminded us last night that all other EU member states had carrier liability legislation which underlined the necessity for us to have a similar framework. Be that as it may, he has not outlined the effect or non-effect of carrier liability legislation throughout Europe. Has it prevented illegals coming into the European Union? It has not. It has had the effect of creating horrendous trafficking, horrific incidents, of which we are well aware.

One year ago this month there was the horrific incident where people were found dead in the back of a container in County Wexford, the driver of which was attempting to gain entry to the United Kingdom, not here. The framework of carrier liability legislation throughout Europe is not working, rather it is having the effect of increasing trafficking. As Senator Ryan said, while there is a sanction in legalisation to deal with traffickers, not enough practical effect has been given to pursing them.