John Paul Phelan (Fine Gael)

I agree with Senator McCarthy and support Senator Quinn's amendment. The wording of section 32(2), which states, "the chief executive shall not question or express an opinion," is quite amazing. Given that we are looking for openness, transparency and accountability in the various Government agencies, it is hard to believe such a clause has been proposed. It is a regressive and draconian step and should not be part of the Bill. I urge Deputy O'Donoghue, who is an enlightened and forward thinking Minister, to accede to Senator Quinn's amendment. He has shown this evening that he is prepared to listen.