Results 10,621-10,640 of 12,320 for speaker:Paul Murphy

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: We are talking about the amendments here.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: Yes.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: Thank you.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: That is what I am speaking about. That is no problem.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: There is lots of time to debate this tonight.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: I am not going around the country.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: Another is Peter Peacock, who favours charges and boasts that consumer forums can help lower prices.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: Another is Ms Sarah Hendry, who is an academic lawyer who teaches a module on how price setting can achieve social and economic objectives. Another is Gritta Nottelman, a strategy consultant with Waternet, a Dutch water company that charges for tap water and the discharge of wastewater. Another is Bill Emery, a former director of Ofwat, the British regulatory authority that presided over a...

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: May we raise a point of order about the ruling out of order of the amendments?

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: The amendments have been ruled out order on the basis that-----

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: I do not understand how they can be out of order on the basis that they are in conflict with the principle of the Bill when all they do is suggest the commission should discuss the issue of water poverty-----

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: You are going to push ahead and we will vote on the Bill and it will then be through; therefore, it will be too late. I have never seen such a narrow interpretation of the rules. In the letter Deputy Ruth Coppinger sent to you earlier, we accepted that some amendments had been ruled out on the basis that they would impose or increase a charge on Revenue. We do not agree with the Standing...

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: We would simply be adding things for the committee to discuss. How does that possibly contradict the principle of Bill?

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: They are.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: Can I read them?

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: It is your interpretation of Standing Orders.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: The effect of your ruling is to give Fianna Fáil an excuse not to vote. I am not saying that was the intention in making your ruling, but it is the effect.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: I am not accusing you of bias.

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: I am not accusing you of bias. We need an explanation as to why these things, including Deputy Jan O'Sullivan's amendments-----

Water Services (Amendment) Bill 2016: Report Stage (12 Jul 2016)

Paul Murphy: It is not a question of implementation but of interpretation.