Results 24,381-24,400 of 28,162 for speaker:Catherine Murphy
- Written Answers — Department of Rural and Community Development: Departmental Websites (6 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: 374. To ask the Minister for Rural and Community Development to clarify whether at any point over the past ten years the SSL certificates for her Department’s websites expired for a period of time; if so, the reason this occurred; and the duration they remained expired. [33279/23]
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: The witnesses are welcome. I will go back to the invoices. The invoices are not a creative document Mr. Kelly. They are intended to be a true record of what services were provided or what work was done. Essentially, both sides were complicit in what the chair of the board said was "an act designed to deceive". Did Mr. Kelly challenge it?
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: NK Management issued the invoices.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: Mr. Kelly has a few companies. He knows what it is to raise an invoice. He took instructions from RTÉ without challenging them and essentially there is a moral and legal imperative around that. I would like to ask Mr. Tubridy-----
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: Mr. Kelly has said all of this before.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: I am moving on.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: "Following instructions" is known as the Nuremburg defence. Is Mr. Tubridy happy about that kind of operation not being challenged? It was being done in his name.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: Is Mr. Tubridy happy with people just following instructions? Mr. Tubridy knows what an invoice is.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: That is not the question.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: That is not the question I am asking. I want to go back to Grant Thornton's second review into the €120,000. We know there was €225,000 and that leaves €75,000. Grant Thornton is conducting another review into the €120,000 from 2017 to 2019. The witnesses are categorically saying that was simply waived. They are saying it was not paid and that RTÉ knew...
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: Mr. Tubridy opened by saying he is a contractor and we all understand-----
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: But RTÉ would not normally find Mr. Tubridy work as an independent contractor, and that is why this-----
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: This is not ordinary and that is why it is impossible for us to separate out-----
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: -----the difference between the Renault contract and Mr. Tubridy's salary.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: It would effectively be a case of RTÉ finding work for Mr. Tubridy, where Mr. Tubridy would normally find that work himself.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: Did Mr. Kelly know that Renault had insisted that the commercial agreement was done on a cost neutral basis?
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: Who would Mr. Kelly normally deal with when he is dealing with the contractual arrangements for his clients in RTÉ?
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: Mr. Kelly would not normally deal with the director general.
- Public Accounts Committee: RTÉ Commercial Arrangements: Mr. Ryan Tubridy and Mr. Noel Kelly (11 Jul 2023)
Catherine Murphy: So Dee Forbes was not the only one who would have been aware of all of this?