Jennifer Carroll MacNeill (Dún Laoghaire, Fine Gael)

I do not know how else to say it to the Deputy but HIQA has verified that all of the recommendations were implemented. Perhaps we should arrange an opportunity for the Deputy to engage with HIQA about its assessment. It is the independent regulator and HIQA advised that they were implemented. One recommendation of 154 did not work and it was moved backwards. The issues that arose in Portiuncula hospital should not have arisen. They should not have happened, because the recommendations of the Walker report were implemented, yet they arose again. I ask myself the same questions. I have asked that of hospital management and I have asked through the reviews.

How is it that the same issues, which are not of resources but of management, culture, communication and responsiveness to women, frankly, are occurring? I have met many of these women. I have sat with them and heard the particular experiences of their cases and what happened to them and their babies. It is difficult to accept that those cases should have happened in circumstances where the Walker report was implemented. If we are going to have a political dialogue about a report that has been implemented, which the independent regulator has confirmed as having been implemented, with one recommendation having been walked back, and try to place what happened to those women at the foot of that single recommendation being changed, we are not in a good space.

See this speech in context