Gerald Nash (Louth, Labour)

The Minister also failed to understand and accept that there has always been churn in the retail and hospitality sectors. There were enormous net job gains in the retail and hospitality sectors in recent years, sectors which, quite rightly, were protected during the pandemic but which have continued to be protected with significant subsidies that have no conditions whatsoever attached to them in terms of job quality, retention or pay.

What the Minister is doing in respect of the living wage is virtue signalling. That is it. It has no basis whatsoever in evidence. This will affect the lowest paid people in our society. The reality is that decent pay boosts productivity and increases retention for SMEs. We know the lower paid have a propensity to spend more of their income in the local community, ensuring that demand continues even if the local economy is in some difficulty. The Minister needs to review his position on the living wage and other employment rights he is attempting to decimate on the sham altar of competitiveness. The essence of social democracy is having decent jobs, a decent economy and good, functioning businesses that offer decent working conditions to people. Unfortunately, the Minister is showing that he is picking sides, and this is unnecessary.

See this speech in context