Matt Carthy (Cavan-Monaghan, Sinn Fein) | Oireachtas source

The Tánaiste is correct that RACO does not agree with him; neither do any of the other representative organisations. Crucially, neither does the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, whose representatives gave evidence to the joint committee that they are unaware of a single other individual in the State who is precluded by legislation from joining a representative organisation. That includes judges, the DPP and everyone else. This would be a new principle established in law where those in a defined category are prevented from joining a representative organisation. Quite frankly, I have not heard a compelling argument. Just to say the Tánaiste does not think they should is not sufficient in that respect.

The oversight body is either going to deliver or it is not. Depending on that will be the actions of Government. If the Tánaiste says it is important to have a conduit with the Department, and I agree there needs to be one, it also stands to reason that there is a conduit to the men and women of the Defence Forces he will be relying on to fulfil all the objectives set out by the oversight body. I urge a rethink on that matter.

See this speech in context