Matt Carthy (Cavan-Monaghan, Sinn Fein) | Oireachtas source

We would have a much better agricultural policy and overall discussion if the Minister was willing to engage on issues. Through our suckler herd we produce some of the most sustainable beef in the world. The associated carbon emissions are half of that coming from South American beef. For the Government to even contemplate a forced reduction of Irish suckler cattle while the Mercosur trade agreement remains on the table would send a bad message to rural communities and would undermine climate action measures. Such a move would be rightly seen as hypocritical and counterproductive.

The suckler image is the brand of Ireland. It is what has given all sectors the reputation across the world as having a premium product. However, it is only sector to see a scheme introduced aimed at reduction through the ill-fated beef exceptional aid measure, BEAM, scheme. I accept that suckler farmers like those in every other sector must utilise every option to reduce emissions, including opportunities for diversification, but why has the Minister not ruled out such a move when he is on record as saying that 25% sectoral reductions can be achieved while "stabilising the herd", to use his language?

See this speech in context