Declan Breathnach (Louth, Fianna Fail) | Oireachtas source

The compromise would allow for the establishments' progression and profitability. Having visited quite a number of them, particularly while on holiday abroad, I have yet to see people overindulge. Those who buy from them, be they on a tour or otherwise, certainly leave the premises in a state of sobriety.

The Minister has raised an issue with the neighbourhood and the suitability of the premises, but it would be addressed in the licensing process. A licence can be refused on "the grounds of the character, misconduct or unfitness of the applicant or of the unfitness or inconvenience of the premises" or the unsuitability of the premises to the needs of persons residing in the neighbourhood. I dare say some of the other licensed premises can be obstreperous at the best of times.

We have said politics is about the art of compromise, but it is equally about reaching a consensus to facilitate this change. I agree with Deputy Alan Kelly that the off-sales aspect can be controlled by the Minister at any stage. The words, "This pack is not to be opened on the premises", could be printed on it. I was not at the committee, but I am sure, outside the legislation, the Minister is capable of reaching agreement. If people visit as tourists, they will sign a book or buy a ticket. Those who visit to collect could simply sign that they would not avail of it on the premises. There could be a little smartness too. They could view the tour on a CD or link. We are picking at crumbs when we should have the legislation passed to let the breweries to progress and move towards profitability. The amendments could be dealt with quickly with a compromise on the part of the Minister.

See this speech in context