Maureen O'Sullivan (Dublin Central, Independent) | Oireachtas source

Part of the history of this project involves the Mater site in Dublin Central. There was a lot of speculation as to why that site was even considered in the first place. In that instance, I do think the right decision was made. I did not feel it was a suitable site. I admit that, if we were starting today, my own preference would be for a greenfield site out in Blanchardstown or Tallaght. However, we have to accept the reality of where we are now. Planning permission has been granted for this site at St. James's. Like others, I think that there would not be 100% agreement, no matter what site was chosen. I am sure there are some now who would like to go back to the Mater site.

What is important, and is covered in both the motion and the amendment, is the commitment to develop a world-class national children's hospital. It is quite incredible to think of the years that have been spent and wasted and the cost to date in getting to this point. Even considering looking at another location now would delay the project further.

I attended the presentations for both locations, St. James's and Connolly in Blanchardstown, and there were compelling arguments from both groups. The more recent presentation was from the St. James's location. One of the arguments that struck me was that Great Ormond Street Hospital in London stayed with its city centre location. They went through all of the issues, such as accommodation, services, trilocation, parking, future expansion, etc. There was argument and counter-argument. There was also the point that there were international and national reports in favour of the St. James's site, which was disputed. What exactly, then, is the truth?

Deputy Harty outlined very valid questions on the extent of the costs. We need to know exactly how much it is going to cost to build and also to fit out the hospital. Why does it cost us so much to build here compared with countries similar to ours, whether it is public transport, a stadium, a hospital or infrastructure? We need a cost-benefit analysis of all the aspects, as well as a timeframe in respect of the hospital and the trilocation issue.

It is really good that the Rural Independent Group Deputies have used their Private Members' time to raise this so that we can get these issues aired. We cannot afford any further delay. The planning permission has been granted for St. James's and the other centres at Blanchardstown and Tallaght.

See this speech in context