Pearse Doherty (Donegal South West, Sinn Fein) | Oireachtas source

I welcome the Minister's response to this proposal, which I have been making for some time. I note from the Official Report of the Dáil that this matter was also raised with the late Minister for Finance, Brian Lenihan, by the Tánaiste when Labour Party Opposition spokesperson on finance and by other Deputies. The provision of this type of process would allow for a proper, realistic and wholesome debate on alternative budgets. However, I ask that the Minister ensure that the process is not only the preserve of Government and that in coming to a decision on the best way to proceed there is engagement with Opposition Deputies, particularly those who hold finance portfolios and those who take these issues seriously in terms of their parliamentary work. The finance committee might also have a role to play in regard to what is proposed. I would encourage that this proposal be proceeded with.

I suggest that to complete the circle we also need to deal with the constitutional amendment. I have tabled legislation on this issue but it was not accepted. That Opposition Deputies cannot table particular amendments to a Finance Bill is archaic. There is a need for reflection on how to ensure proper debate on finance legislation. That Opposition Deputies cannot table particular amendments for discussion on Committee Stage does not allow for full debate.

See this speech in context