Alex White (Dublin South, Labour) | Oireachtas source

I have no wish to trespass on the particular issue, but where there is a difference in point of view there is likely to be a controversy. The fact that we have a particular viewpoint on an issue and others have a different view would seem to point to the existence of a controversy. The fact results from people disagreeing with a particular decision. I am at pains to emphasise that I am not trespassing on the particular issue. However, the fact that Deputy Murphy, I or others might think something is wrong or might disagree with a decision made does not impugn the integrity of the body or third party making that decision. The point is to take it away from the political system or any third party other than one set up properly under legislation.

I respect that Deputy Murphy has raised this issue, but he made a point about whether the BAI is acting in accordance with legislation. I have no reason to believe from anything that I have seen from the BAI in this regard or anything with respect to what the Deputy has said this afternoon, even remotely, that the BAI is not acting in accordance with the legislation.

Reference was made to the codes the BAI has published. As I understand it, these were done after a lengthy consultation period. I am unsure whether the issue relates to the code or the particular outcome.

Another point is relevant to this issue. This morning, on my nomination, the Government agreed to appoint five new members to the broadcasting authority because the term of office of the previous authority had come to an end. I thank the outgoing members of the BAI under the leadership of Bob Collins. The new members will take up office immediately under the chairmanship of Dr. Pauric Travers.

See this speech in context