Róisín Shortall (Dublin North West, Independent) | Oireachtas source

This amendment is about the reporting and notification mechanism in the legislation, which is really important for most people. As was discussed at the hearings and on Committee Stage, legislating in this area is a new departure in many ways. I have already said I do not believe it is the intention of the Minister or the Government to introduce any kind of liberal regime, but because of the nature of the legislation's provisions there is obviously a concern that it may lead to a significant increase in the rate of terminations, which most people do not want to see. It is impossible to say at this stage what the impact of the legislation will be. For that reason it is important to have a very clear notification system so that as legislators we know the impact of the legislation through periodic reports.

The legislation provides for a certain amount of reporting. In addition to those covered in sections 20(3)(a) to (d), inclusive, I am suggesting adding two other categories which would provide for an anonymised reporting arrangement outlining the stage of gestation at which terminations take place and the outcome for both the woman and unborn. It is reasonable for us to have access to that information, which would, of course, be entirely anonymised. On the basis of those notifications and the information that is gathered, the Minister should prepare an annual report on it. I believe that amendment strengthens the section and gives people a clearer picture of the impact of the legislation.

My understanding of the additional amendment tabled by the Minister is that it greatly weakens the reporting arrangements. I will talk about that when we deal with the Minister's amendment which will be taken next. I believe my amendment No. 145 strengthens the legislation and provides a clearer and more comprehensive picture of the impact of the legislation. I believe it is reasonable and I hope the Government might consider supporting it.

See this speech in context