Alex White (Dublin South, Labour) | Oireachtas source

I take the points made by both Deputies. On Deputy Calleary's remark on the desirability and necessity for consistency, I would be concerned about this and when I have an opportunity, I would like to find out more about it. It would not make sense if there was an inconsistency across the country for any service.

I would not regard it, however, as bizarre that we should have a system in place for determining the efficacy of devices, procedures or drugs. I am sure the practitioner concerned is eminent and has carried out the studies referred to by Deputy Naughten and serious regard should be had to them. I hold the view, however, that we have a system in place that makes determination on efficacy and appropriateness of devices and medication across the system and we should rely on that.

I cannot say any more than I already have. There is an inquiry being carried out by the national clinic care programme on this but I have taken on board the remarks made by the Deputies.

See this speech in context