Frances Fitzgerald (Dublin Mid West, Fine Gael) | Oireachtas source

It is not correct to state there has been no support for childminders. Clearly, a decision was taken to exempt childminders who are looking after fewer than three children. I take it from the Deputy's question that he and his party support the regulation of childminders and babysitters. Very different views have been expressed on this by parents. Many parents want to make their own decisions on whether they want a particular individual minding their child. There are many different views on the question of State intervention in the decision by parents. It is a question of what is in the best interest of the child. I want to see the best supports possible put in place for childminders.

The question of the type of regulation that is most suitable is one that requires serious consideration. Some countries have opted for very heavy regulation in this area while others have opted for none at all. In Ireland, we have encouraged childminders to register voluntarily. We have given them tax relief on earnings and have set up supports for them in the form of the local child care committees. It is interesting that only 1,200 have registered. This is an area on which we need to focus more to ensure women minding children in their homes feel supported, if they are seeking support, and have expertise available to them. Parents will become increasingly interested in more regulation in this area given some of the recent incidents about which we have heard, although not so much in Ireland. Clearly, this is an area of concern. We must strike a balance in the regulation and this is why I have asked the early-years group to examine the matter. I include Childminding Ireland, with which I have had much contact.

The point raised by the Deputy is certainly one we need to examine. We will need to examine carefully the precise form of regulation and its depth. Many parents have expressed the view that they do not want to see heavy regulation as they believe regulation should be left to parents themselves. We will examine the matter. The early-years group is doing so and I look forward to seeing the recommendations it brings forward. I take it that the Deputy is proposing regulation of the entire sector.

See this speech in context