Finian McGrath (Dublin North Central, Independent) | Oireachtas source

I am putting forward another point of view, I am not misleading House. I am asking questions about the Minister's figures and am entitled to do so. He may answer them later if he wants to do so.

The expert report issued before the ban instigated by former Minister, Deputy Martin was couched in numerous caveats, such as "may be", "could be" and "might be". One matter is clear however - the conclusion recommends further research to assess the dangers of environmental tobacco smoke, particularly in the hospitality industry. To suggest that such a report is unequivocal in demanding a ban on smoking in the workplace is bending the truth to an outrageous degree. I am only asking the questions. I am asking the experts to consider their own reports, in which I am picking out flaws, as is my democratic right. The nanny state brigade in this House will not bully me or get me off the pitch in regard to that issue.

See this speech in context