Billy Kelleher (Cork North Central, Fianna Fail)

I thank the Minister for his reply. The publication of a contingency plan was raised on numerous occasions on this side of the House. The plan would not only give reassurance to us but also to the public and those involved in health services.

In response to questions from the leader of Fianna Fáil and other Deputies, the Taoiseach was unsure whether there was a plan. He stated at one stage we can take it the HSE has a plan. However, when we asked for further detail and specific information, it became very evident that a plan was only being put in place. The Minister has known since taking office that a large number would be retiring on 29 February 2012, many of whom will be highly skilled specialists in front line services. Merlin Park hospital in Galway should have 21 nurses but it will have only 11 at the end of February. Clearly, there will be considerable difficulties faced by the HSE and hospital services in providing front line services. Does the Minister agree with some eminent professionals at the coalface in maternity services who say people may pay with their lives because of the lack of highly qualified midwives?

Why will the plan not be published? Does the Minister agree that the efforts of the Department and HSE in ensuring adequate front line cover for those retiring are an indication that the plan was not well thought out?

See this speech in context