Brendan Howlin (Wexford, Labour)

The Deputy has already asked. I suggest she asks any lawyer for advice and she will get something similar.

She used the word "proportionate". The action relating to the public service in terms of the volume of levy has to be proportionate to that across society in general. We cannot have a confiscatory amount for one narrow group and that is the advice. The Deputy's characterisation of an effective rate of taxation of 70% as meaning these people cannot be touched is grandstanding and is trying to pander to populism. A rate of 70% touches salaries significantly. I acknowledge that often gross figures are given out but the net impact is what is important and I ask Members to remember that in their commentary. I am minded for the reasons outlined not to accept the amendment.

See this speech in context