Michael Creed (Cork North West, Fine Gael)

Does the Minister accept that at the heart of this dilemma of drawing a line in respect of entitlement is the fact that for many years we failed to develop an integrated tax and social welfare system? That is one of the reasons, on which I do not wish to dwell, we are in this financial difficulty. However, a bigger failing of previous Administrations of all hues was that they failed to develop an integrated tax and social welfare system which would have allowed us to deliver resources in a more targeted way, especially at a time when resources were scarce. It is that failure which leaves us with little or no option but to endeavour to make savings. I accept the point being made that when one draws a line, one may fall off the cliff. However, if we had an integrated tax and social welfare system, under which there would be a more progressive wind-down of entitlement, we would not face these difficult choices. While I accept the necessity to make the changes and cuts proposed, will the Minister give a commitment that this time next year when we will again be looking at tax and social welfare issues, there will be the capacity to adopt a more progressive approach in targeting resources where they are most needed?

See this speech in context