Jonathan O'Brien (Cork North Central, Sinn Fein)

The Minister referred to section 2(1)(b). We are not disputing that there may be cases where lethal force has to be used to protect oneself, one's family or individuals within the home. However, it is not correct to say the Bill would not exclude the use of lethal force just to protect private property - bricks and mortar. Section 2(1)(b)(ii) states: "to protect his or her property or the property of another person from appropriation, destruction or damage caused by a criminal act". That is the subsection we have an issue with. We do not believe it is robust enough and it does not comply with Article 2. For that reason, we will seek a vote on the amendment.

See this speech in context