Barry Andrews (Dún Laoghaire, Fianna Fail)

I do not intend to change this area. It is not clear from Deputy Shatter's proposal or comments what he is trying to correct and what problem is to be addressed. There is an arbitrary nature in picking a certain age in any respect and all of us would have different views as to when a child might be properly consulted about something as significant as an adoption. In any case, section 24 - as already pointed out by the Deputy - already ensures that a child reaching the age of seven can be adopted and in those circumstances due regard is had for the wishes of the child, with the safeguard that regard would be had for the child's best interest. This is mirrored to some extent in other parts of the law where a child's own wishes may not be in his or her best interests. Such issues must be distinguished, which is why this element is in the Bill. It is not my intention to change the law in this area.

See this speech in context