Brian Cowen (Laois-Offaly, Fianna Fail)

We have serious reservations regarding the decision to re-engage in negotiations with the Mercosur countries - Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay. While it is the European Commission's decision to relaunch the negotiations, we note that there are major differences between the expectations of both sides. We are, therefore, doubtful that there is a sound basis for a positive engagement or outcome. At the time of the suspension of the previous talks in 2004, Ireland had difficulties with the substance of the negotiations, particularly in regard to market access for beef. I am also concerned that the relaunch could have a very negative impact on the Doha round and could leave the EU with little negotiating capital in that round.

The Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food, Deputy Smith, has been very active in respect of this matter and succeeded in having it fully discussed at the Agricultural Council meeting on 17 May. Ireland, France, Austria, Finland, Greece, Hungary and Poland voiced their shared concerns regarding the potential impact of this matter on the EU agricultural sector, particularly the beef market. We asked the Commission to provide a detailed analysis of the impact of the negotiations and to clarify the terms and conditions under which they are being relaunched. Commissioner Ciolos has reassured member states that he is well aware of their concerns and will be vigilant in ensuring that EU agriculture will be properly protected. The relaunch of the EU-Mercosur trade talks could jeopardise a successful outcome to the stalled WTO negotiations because it reduces the incentive for Mercosur to commit to the conclusion of the Doha development round.

I do not have any detailed information regarding the statement by the President of Haiti or on the EU's follow-up actions regarding the disaster in that country. However, I will pursue the matter and communicate further with the Deputy on it. I recall that the Haitian delegation issued a message of thanks to the European Union on the work it is doing. The delegation also provided a report on the progress that has been made. As the Deputy is aware, the Haitian people still face a considerable challenge and there is a need for continuing and effective support for the rehabilitation of their country. I will check what additional initiatives have been put in place to augment the EU's initial response and revert to the Deputy on the matter.

I did not have an opportunity to raise with the Bolivian President the other matter to which Deputy Gilmore referred.

See this speech in context