Noel Dempsey (Meath West, Fianna Fail)

It is true that the Government reappointed Dr. Lynch on my recommendation. I do not think the Deputy is comparing like with like. Dr. Lynch is an executive chairman and that is a completely different situation from appointing a member of the board. I reappointed him on a three monthly rolling basis for 12 months in order to ensure continuity at the company at this critical juncture. It is not any secret that the finances of CIE are in a very precarious position. There have been ongoing negotiations on change, including the implementation of the Deloitte report. Dr. Lynch has a very "hands on" approach to these matters, so I felt it was in the best interests of the company that he continue in his role for up to 12 months.

Different issues will have to be discussed. Dr. Lynch went in there at a particular time for particular reasons. The company was not in great shape at the time and it had been involved in various controversies. He was appointed because of his expertise and experience. He has done well on that but the question now arises as to whether or not there is a necessity to continue with the role of an executive chairperson. That is something we could discuss at some time in the future.

See this speech in context