Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin (Cavan-Monaghan, Sinn Fein)

The Sinn Féin Members do not agree to taking this motion, which seeks approval for the dissolution of the NESF without debate. It is not acceptable, as this matter should be debated. When one considers it against the backdrop of the Government having already abolished the Combat Poverty Agency at a time in which more and more people are being driven into poverty, it would appear that the Government is intent on abolishing all of the watchdog bodies that have been established over the years. This is simply not good enough.

Over the years, the NESF has produced many fine reports. Some of what it has produced has found its way into Government policy, but much of its focus, which is mainly concentrated on issues of equality and social inclusion, has not been taken up by the Government. More than likely, it was an embarrassment to the Government. This is what is behind the proposition to abolish the NESF.

From the Sinn Féin point of view, it is not only taking the matter without debate that would be opposed by our Members. We would oppose the proposition full stop. This body has played a useful and worthwhile role and the quality of its material over the years, including the 2002 report on equity in acute hospital care, the 2005 report on the large child care deficit and its last report in October concerning the home care package scheme, which the NESF claimed was being stymied by bad implementation, has been critical. The reports were valued and welcomed by those who want to see equity and social inclusion in this State.

See this speech in context