Eamon Ryan (Dublin South, Green Party)

I accept that fairness has a part of play. I have a similar concern to the Deputy's regarding the jobs of those in broadcasters across the State, particularly in the independent radio broadcasting sector, that are facing difficult times in terms of advertising revenue that has fallen dramatically and the change in the nature of the broadcasting market. There is fairness in the sense that the public service broadcaster will bear the largest burden in the form of payment of a levy, as is right.

A benefit of an industry-funded regulator is that one gets a proper, fair and independent regulation of the sector. This is in the commercial and employment interests of everyone involved in the sector. We knew this would be difficult. It was flagged at various stages throughout the legislative process. However, our experience of independent regulation funded by the industry is a positive one.

I agree that this is a difficult time. The authority has told the chief executive that there is a particular difficulty and asked him to examine the Estimate. He is due to revert on the matter because everyone, including members of the authority, is aware of the difficult times people are facing.

See this speech in context