Chris Andrews (Dublin South East, Fianna Fail)

I am delighted to have an opportunity to contribute to the debate as a former member of the authority during my time as a Dublin city councillor. It is important to note that many good initiatives were undertaken in the docklands leading to extensive community development, which transformed a derelict area into a vibrant community both on the north side and the south side. Deputy Costello identified a number of projects on the north side that were not undertaken but the docklands must be considered in its entirely. With regard to housing provision, it transformed people's lives, giving them great self-esteem. They moved from miserable accommodation in the locality to decent, good quality accommodation and that has made a difference to individuals and the community at large.

The Minister touched on a number of achievements in education and the authority's positive contribution in facilitating sporting organisations and groups. Children and parents worked together on different projects to build their relationships, including fathers and daughters. A new theatre will open in the area, which is positive, and various art exhibitions are held there, which have made a difference to the arts community. The docklands is a good template for future planning because it integrated the existing small community into the new larger community. The joining of the old community with the new vibrant community was almost seamless. This did not happen in other developments. As I stated at the joint committee meeting last week, there was a sense in the community at the time that this positive community development should be extended to Poolbeg. People in Ringsend and further afield on both sides of the river said this made sense because it has worked.

There are serious issues and Deputy Hogan's Bill has merit but it is great in hindsight to be able to say it was not a good idea. This development should be considered as a template for an extension to Poolbeg. I stated at last week's committee meeting that the merger of the authority with Dublin City Council should be examined. This proposal has merit in that there is a great deal of crossover between both bodies. However, the chairman made a strong case for retaining the authority as a separate entity. It would be clean and clear.

Deputy Hogan's Bill has merit but we have to wait on the two reports commissioned by the Minister. The Bill is premature but not without merit.

See this speech in context