Martin Mansergh (Tipperary South, Fianna Fail)

I thank Deputies for their support. As most of us are aware, Ireland has a very long coastline and has been vulnerable to smuggling for centuries. I note Deputy Hogan's comments about coal smuggling and am sure the relevant agencies are aware of the matter.

I agree with Deputy Burton regarding the costs of cigarette smuggling in terms of undermining social solidarity, taking badly needed funds from the Exchequer and impacting on health. Although we must not be under any illusion about how much smuggling we can prevent, we are stepping up our efforts in this regard. I do not think the Deputy is correct in regard to penalties. On 13 October 2009, the Minister for Finance stated:

The penalties for cigarette smuggling provided under legislation on summary conviction, are a monetary fine not exceeding €5,000 and/or a custodial sentence not exceeding 12 months. These are the maximum penalties that can be imposed at District Court level. The penalties for conviction on indictment are €12,695 or treble the duty-paid value, whichever is the greater, and/or a custodial sentence not exceeding 5 years. These penalties are considered adequate.

See this speech in context