Áine Brady (Kildare North, Fianna Fail)

The protocol is clear that the primary concern is for the welfare of the minor. Without test purchasing, it is difficult to know how under-age sales could be policed. The period of suspension is mandatory. The penalties apply to many offences other than the sale of cigarettes to minors. It was decided, for the reasons already outlined, that judicial discretion was the best option. I regret I am unable to accept the amendments. I must add that the policy decision was taken before my ministerial appointment and that the enforcement of the legislation will be monitored.

See this speech in context