Brian Lenihan Jnr (Dublin West, Fianna Fail)

A large number of constructive questions were asked and I appreciate the tone of the House at this time. I am not in a position to deal with all of the questions because so many were asked.

To answer Deputy Barrett, we decided to use gross income as the basis of this measure and I will take his point about lending money to facilitate alternative energies. It is an important issue and I am aware the National Treasury Management Agency has been involved in this matter with regard to the interconnector.

Deputy Rabbitte returned to the subject of the total contribution coming from one sector and the fact that the nature of the progression was unfair. Across the Civil Service at all grades and on all pay scales from clerical officer to principal officer, the total deductions are higher as a percentage of gross pay as pay increases. However, we will have an opportunity in the context of the Bill to develop these matters at greater length.

See this speech in context