Ulick Burke (Galway East, Fine Gael)

I welcome the opportunity to say a few words on this Bill. When we examine some of the legislation on alcohol that already exists, we have to wonder if sufficient legislation is already in place. The only problem seems to be that it is not being effectively applied. There is no use in blaming the Garda. If the Garda had sufficient resources and numbers, many of the difficulties caused by the abuse of alcohol could be easily tightened up. I am glad to see that one of the points that the advisory group on alcohol raised related to the adequacy and effectiveness of existing sanctions and penalties. That is the kernel of the problem.

When we tried to eliminate the sale of tobacco to under age people, health board officials sent minors into shops to buy cigarettes in order to catch out the retail agent. I do not agree with that, but this Bill is even worse as gardaí will be able to send a minor, with parental permission, into an outlet to try to purchase alcohol. That is a retrograde step, because such a minor will become a hero among his peers. I ask the Minister of State to bring this issue to the notice of the Minister. It should be withdrawn from this Bill. It is an admission that the law is unable to monitor adequately the difficulties surrounding the sale of drink at existing outlets. Using a minor to purchase alcohol is to renege on our responsibilities.

About six weeks ago, I raised a matter on the Adjournment that dealt with the importation of what are known as "shots" from Mexico, the US and Canada. These drinks are targeted at young people and contain 80% alcohol. The company's marketing statement claims that it has revolutionised the alcohol industry by introducing a single shot premium liqueur in a lightweight and durable plastic pouch. It states that the 50 ml shots come in a safe, break-resistant plastic pouch which makes them safer than glass, and have a built-in spout that makes them ready to use in any location.

See this speech in context