Eamon Gilmore (Dún Laoghaire, Labour)

Much of the post-referendum and post-summit speculation focused on the idea that there will be a second referendum. Let us put that aside for the moment because I cannot see how we can have a second referendum on the same proposition. Let us say that the other 26 states proceed with ratification. I heard what the Taoiseach had to say about the situation in the Czech Republic but let us assume that the 26 states proceed to ratify when we have not. The Lisbon treaty cannot come into effect. A range of issues relating to the Charter of Fundamental Rights and the change from unanimity to qualified majority voting, the common energy policy and other matters provided for in Lisbon will not go ahead. The immediate issue that arises is the membership of the European Parliament and the Commission. Was consideration given to the European Parliament elections, which are less than a year away? On what basis will European Parliament elections take place — on the basis of the Nice or Lisbon formula? It is a pressing issue.

The Nice formula provides that membership of the Commission is to be reduced from 27 to an unspecified number from next year. The Lisbon formula was that the Commission would be reduced to 18 from 2014. We are operating with the Nice formula on the basis that the Lisbon treaty cannot be ratified. In 2009 the Commission membership will be reduced. Is consideration being given to the way in which that will be done? If it is not done, by having a reduction of zero, where do we stand on the appointment of a Commissioner next year? Has there been discussion on how portfolios would be allocated?

See this speech in context