Joe McHugh (Donegal North East, Fine Gael)

We are looking at sacrificing an industry. Ireland is the fourth largest exporter of beef in the world. I respect the Minister as a fellow representative of Donegal. I acknowledge the difficulty of her job. Deputy Creed mentioned the possibility that she may be moving to another Department. If she demonstrates her competence in the next two weeks, she might be able to stay where she is. I would be delighted if that happened. I will give her every credit for the efforts she will make as part of the trade talks. Commissioner Mandelson and the Commission are looking at addressing the problems of 3.5% accelerated inflation, the economic downturn and food production as a way out of this scenario and the reduction of 70% tariffs to do so. This will not happen. It will be a complete injustice and disservice to Irish farmers in terms of cost compliance and traceability compliance, as my leader, Deputy Kenny, stated. The efforts and investment we make in quality and food production will be out the window. We will be left in limbo with 50,000 jobs lost. The Minister has a responsibility and the Cabinet has collective responsibility to do so. I implore the Minister to fly the flag for Irish farmers, families and communities in this round of talks.

See this speech in context