Eamon Gilmore (Dún Laoghaire, Labour)

I agree with the comments made by Deputy Kenny. I raised this issue last week and tabled an amendment to the Government motion today in the terms Deputy Kenny has outlined, namely, that we would proceed with the reappointment of Mr. Justice Smith as chairperson of the Standards in Public Office Commission and that the appointment of the ordinary member would be deferred to allow for consultation and discussion between the parties in the House. The Ceann Comhairle has ruled that the amendment is inadmissible for the reasons he outlined in a letter to me, which I accept.

There is no issue with regard to Mr. Michael Smith's suitability or otherwise for appointment. The issue is that this is an appointment that is made following a resolution of the House and there should be consultation between the parties on that matter. As Deputy Kenny pointed out, the Tánaiste made an offer during the week that he would appoint a member of the Opposition to this position when it arises again in six years' time.

See this speech in context